What To Mix with Fireball Whiskey (20 Best Mixers)

You are currently viewing What To Mix with Fireball Whiskey (20 Best Mixers)

Fireball whiskey is indeed a fireball with its explosive cinnamon flavor. It is highly flavorful and aromatic, sweet enough to make the cinnamon bearable, and fiery enough to remind you that it is a whiskey that you are having. 

When you hear Fireball Whiskey, I bet that the first thing that comes to mind is a party accompanied by more than a few fiery Fireball shots, but that’s not the only way to have this whiskey. 

In fact, it has been unjustly labeled as a shot whiskey when it has so much more to offer. Now, don’t get me wrong, Fireball shots are great, but Fireball Whiskey is far more versatile, and it deserves to be enjoyed in other ways. 

The sweet and cinnamon flavors combined in the Fireball whiskey make an excellent base for many other flavor pairs and experiments. 

The sweetness makes it easy to mix Fireball with other bitter or sour ingredients. On the other hand, the expressed cinnamon notes make the Fireball Whiskey an excellent pair with sweet and creamy beverages. 

As much as it is popular among college students, making you think that it is just a cheap, low-budget spirit, Fireball is actually a pretty smooth and exciting drink. It starts with discrete cinnamon notes, increasing in intensity mid-palate, accompanied by sweet flavors and a creamy texture. 

It has a rather unusual finish, exceptionally uncommon for its category. Namely, while whiskeys, in general, have an intense finish, the Fireball Whiskey finish is smooth and very tame. It doesn’t burn you as other spirits would, and it is so refreshing, almost menthol-like. 


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Fireball Whisky NZ 18+ only (@fireball_nz)

Underpriced and highly available, costing about $20 per 700 ml. bottle, the Fireball Whiskey is not expensive enough to be regarded as a top-shelf product. This could not be further from the truth, as it is a good quality spirit, sadly overlooked and mainly used for shots. 

It is aged whiskey, maturing in bourbon barrels before bottling. The downside of the Fireball Whiskey is that it uses sweeteners, meaning the flavor is not all natural.

Its base is Canadian whiskey, while it gets the recognizable flavor from the aforementioned sweetener as well as the generous amount of cinnamon added to the spirit. 

Fireball Whiskey, although seeming restrictive, offers a broad palate of mixing options, and I am confident that you will find a combination that resonates with you.

The expressive cinnamon notes give you the impression that this is a hot and burning whiskey, but may you just have been using it the wrong way. 

20 Best Fireball Whiskey Mixers 

To help you gain another perspective on Fireball Whiskey, in the following article, I will give you a list of ideas on how to mix it so that you can enjoy it from another point of view. 

1. Tea

Who would think that a simple cup of tea could be of the best possible option to mix Fireball with? Make yourself a pleasant and soothing cup of herbal tea and pour some Fireball Whiskey inside. 

Since I highly doubt it that you will order this combination elsewhere, herbal tea and Fireball is a fantastic way to spend an evening at home, curled up under a blanket. To make things even better, add a teaspoon of honey and a few drops of lemon to your Fireball tea. 

2. Pink Lemonade 

Pink lemonade is definitely the way to go if you like mixing your Fireball with gentler drinks to tone it down. The pink lemonade, all sweet and sour at the same time, is an excellent companion to the Fireball. Both complement each other exceptionally well. 

The pink lemonade gets a somewhat wild dimension, while the Fireball gets a sense of refinement from the pink lemonade. These two are definitely an excellent pair making a refreshing, sweet, and enjoyable cocktail with some edge and adventure. 

3. Pineapple Juice

Sweet, thick, and creamy, pineapple juice can be a Fireball predecessor, companion, and a follower. 

With its high viscosity, it layers the throat and helps you handle a Fireball shot better. As a chaser, it impacts the Fireball flavor, intensifying its menthol finish. As a companion, pineapple juice mixes incredibly well with the cinnamon zest and sweetness of the Fireball, creating an entirely different story. 

No matter in which way you have it, pairing Fireball and pineapple juice is an idea that works from all angles.

4. Coke

Uncommon for many of the two-ingredient cocktails, in this one, the whisky to coke ratio matters. Ad one part whiskey and two parts coke to achieve the best possible flavor. Since Coke is a very sweet beverage but sharp nevertheless, it is important not to overdo it with the sharpness of the whiskey. 

The Fireball whiskey and coke combination is one of the most common, as it is very easy to make, and everyone has Coke at home. The sweetness of the Coke tames the aggressiveness of the Fireball, while the coke bubbles intensify the cinnamon notes. 

As a result, you will get a high viscosity, candy-like drink you will most certainly enjoy.

5. Baileys Irish Cream 

Silky, creamy, thick, and delicious, Baileys Irish cream is an elegant drink intended to tone down the sharpness of alcohol. 

The intensity of the Fireball’s recognizable expressive cinnamon notes will be toned down, whereby its sweetness is accentuated by the Baileys. You can add as much as you want of the Baileys in your Fireball glass and adjust the ratio with each sip. 

However, since Baileys also contains alcohol, don’t go overboard with the Fireball-Baileys mix. 

6. Ginger Ale

Mixing Fireball whiskey with ginger ale is definitely a great idea, especially if you like edgy and zesty flavors. If you find this flavor combination delicious but a little too strong, milden it up with some pineapple juice. 

However, mixing cinnamon and ginger flavors can be a little overbearing on the palate, so chase this mixture with cold water. 

7. Lemon-Lime Soda 

There is something about the citrus freshness that pairs up with the fire and edge of the cinnamon-dominated Fireball whiskey. You can either chase a shot with a large sip of lemon-lime soda or, even better, mix the Fireball and lemon-lime in the same glass. 

Adjust the quantities as you prefer, but see that the Fireball amount does not exceed that of the lemon-lime soda. The thing is, the lemon-lime soda is a fizzy drink, which, mixed with a generous amount of Fireball, can create a real fireball in your mouth, triggering an irritating sensation. 

Therefore, stay on the safe side and mix less Fireball Whiskey with more lemon-lime soda. The sweetness of the Fireball Whiskey will come to light, provoked by the citrus freshness of the lemon-lime soda. In turn, the cinnamon flavor of the Fireball will accentuate the fruitiness that the lemon-lime soda brings. 

8. RumChata

Made of rum, dairy cream, and spices, the RumChata liquor mixes great with Fireball Whiskey. The flavors of both drinks complement each other very well. The sweetness of the Fireball, mixed with the creaminess of the RumChata, accompanied with the cinnamon and spices, will catapult your right back to your childhood. 

The entire flavor ensemble results in a milky, creamy, grainy, and sweet combination. For some extra crunch, dip the rim of the glass in a cinnamon and sugar mixture. 

9. Hot Chocolate

It is no secret that hot chocolate and whiskey go perfectly together. The sharpness of the whiskey benefits from the gentility of the chocolate, while the chocolate can handle the fiery alcohol. 

Fireball and hot chocolate are not an exception to this rule. Mix equal parts Fireball and hot chocolate and enjoy the playfulness of the flavors, different with each sip. You will notice that some sips are more chocolaty, while other ones are dominated by the cinnamon. 

There’s another way to combine Fireball and hot chocolate, and that is to make whiskey-spiked hot chocolate. Add a few drops of Fireball to your hot chocolate, and you have a delicious and a bit edgy nightcap. 

10. Orange Juice

Orange juiceOrange juice is a signature ingredient for cocktails and a constituent to many famous cocktails, from a screwdriver to tequila sunrise. Mixing orange juice and Fireball whiskey is a great idea, as the cinnamon flavor and the orange work insanely well together. 

The orange does this awesome thing intensifying and toning down the cinnamon intensity. It also amplifies the sweetness of the Fireball, giving it a honey note. You can also add some triple-sec and decorate it with orange slices.

11. Apple Cider 

Apple Cider Apple and cinnamon have been great companions since the beginning of time, and it is no wonder apple cider made it on this list. Mildly bubbly and plenty delicious, the apple cider gives the Fireball whiskey a very natural and earthy dimension. 

In turn, the cinnamon intensity makes the apple cider flavor even more playful and colorful. The entire package gives you the feel of having something between bubbly juice and tea. This is definitely an excellent way to spend an afternoon.

12. Apple Juice 

The apple juice and Fireball combination is very similar to the apple cider and Fireball combo but a little more tender since the juice isn’t bubbly. The tea dimension is more expressed in this mix, with the sweetness of both the Fireball and apple juice as well. 

Think of this mix as the tamer sibling of the previous one, the one containing apple cider. You can also combine this combination with biscuits or pretzels. 

13. Coffee

Whiskey-spiked coffee is one of the best whiskey mixes, and Fireball whiskey spiked coffee is even better. Not only that coffee and whiskey have a long history together, but coffee and cinnamon have been buddies since forever ago. 

Therefore, both dominant aspects of the Fireball whiskey are amazingly compatible with coffee. Add a few drops of your Fireball whiskey to your coffee mug, and you have a delicious warm drink. If you are feeling mellow and festive, add some cream on top of your coffee and pour a bit of Fireball on top of it. 

14. Cream Soda

The cream soda and Fireball Whiskey have contrasting flavors, whereby the cream soda is mild and silky, while the Fireball and strong and spicy. This flavor contrast works excellently in a single glass. You should mix two-thirds cream soda and one-third Fireball whiskey. 

The Fireball will intertwine nicely with the cream soda, making it more of a Fireball-spiked cream soda than a cocktail. Nevertheless, you will love the silkiness and gentility of this combination. 

15. Cherry Liquor 

Creamy, sweet, and fruity, a cherry liquor is a delight in itself but mixed with the cinnamon-dominated Fireball cocktail, it gets an entirely different dimension. The cherry and cinnamon flavor combination results in a cookie-like flavor you won’t be able to resist. 

Let the cherry dominate this mix, as the cinnamon will be an excellent supporter here. The tone that the cherry liquor sets in this combination will pave the way for the cinnamon dimension to step in. 

16. Caramel Liquor 

Caramel liquor works great as a Fireball Whiskey pair. It slides right in place with the cinnamon, giving it a dessert-like flavor and texture. Here too, it is best that you give the lead to the caramel liquor and let the Fireball follow the already established note. 

The caramel liquor will set the tone for the entire mix-creamy, gentle, and silky. The Fireball whiskey will only add cinnamon notes and intensify the sweetness.

Related: What To Mix With Hennessy

17. Hard Cider

Pour a shot of Fireball Whiskey into a glass of hard cider, any brand or flavor you like, and add ice. You can also add a few lemon drops and give it a citrus note. The ice is a compulsory part here, as the cider and Fireball whiskey may be a bit too much for the palate. 

The ice will do an excellent job mildening up the flavors and toning the sharpness down. 

18. Carrot Juice 

Sweet, smooth, fresh, and playful, carrot juice and Fireball Whiskey may be one of the best flavor combinations on this list. The carrot and cinnamon go hand in hand with the sweetness of the carrot juice interlaced with the sweetness of the Fireball Whiskey. 

The smooth texture of the carrot juice and its high viscosity will layer your palate and throat, making each sip more enjoyable than the previous one. 

Since both ingredients in this mix are intense-flavored, mi and match until you get the taste, you enjoy the most. I would recommend you mix equal parts carrot juice and Fireball whiskey for the best flavor balance. 

19. Hot Sauce 

If you like the more extreme things in life than, the hot sauce and Fireball Whiskey is the right mix for you. Choose your hot sauce wisely, as your experimenting experience can take a wrong turn. 

Don’t go overboard, and go one tiny step after another, as this is not the place to be brave. 

It is better to select a mildly hot sauce that won’t add up too much spiciness. You can always take it up a notch by adding more. Never start with an eye-watering hot sauce, as it will ruin your Fireball experience before it even starts.

20. Sangria

Sangria and Fireball Whiskey is a pretty intense combination, but it works on many levels. The fruity, sweet, and refreshing sangria will mix perfectly with the sweet, zesty, and cinnamon-flavored Fireball Whiskey. 

Mix equal parts sangria and Fireball Whiskey and let the battle of flavors begin. Each sip will taste differently, depending on which flavor is dominant. Leave the fresh fruits to float in the glass and add natural and refreshing notes. 

What To Mix With Fireball Easy?

Fireball is a very versatile spirit mixing well with many drinks. The best thing about mixing Fireball is that you can make two-ingredient mixes quickly and easily. 

If you like refreshing drinks, mix your Fireball with apple cider, apple juice, orange soda or orange juice, mint juice, regular soda, or hard cider. 

If you like a dessert in a glass, mix your Fireball with cherry or caramel liquor, but let them dominate the MX. The creamy sweetness of the liquor tones down the spikiness of the Fireball while accentuating the sweetness. You will get something like whiskey-soaked cookies; you will love it. 

If you enjoy the edgier things in life, mix your Fireball with hot sauce or sangria to get more of a kick, in addition to enjoying the taste. 

If you like imagination, you can always mix your Fireball with Coke, and if you are in the mood for a warm cozy evening, mix it with tea, coffee, or hot chocolate. 

Fireball and Coke 

Fireball and Coke are one of the best-known pairs ever. They go incredibly well, giving you a remarkably flavorful and aromatic beverage. Three parts coke and one part Fireball is the recommended dosage, but feel free to adjust it any way you like it. 

The sweetness and high viscosity of the Coke is a perfect match for the fiery Fireball, toning down its aggressiveness and bringing out its sweetness. 

These two bring out the best in each other, complementing in flavor, aroma, and consistency, making up for what the other one lacks. The burn after a sip of Coke and Fireball is virtually non-existent, so expect a smooth and enjoyable ride. 

More: What To Mix With Jack Daniels Honey

Best Soft Drink To Mix with Fireball

Sodas are the best soft drinks to mix with Fireball. They come in many flavors, and the best thing is that each soda flavor collaborates great with Fireball. 

From Coke to Sprite, to Mountain Dew and more, each of them branching out to other flavors particular for the brand, expect a flavor explosion every time you mix your Fireball with soda. 

Each soda brings something different to the table. Some make the mix refreshing and sweet, some make it edgy, and some sweeten it up overall. 

Do not hesitate to mix your Fireball with any type of soda you like, even if the taste doesn’t seem to combine well at first glance. 

What Is Cola and Fireball Called?

The Fireball and cola mix is called the Fireball Cola Slush. It is a simple three-ingredient mix containing cola, Fireball, and a cherry. The cherry is purely decorative. You can make it with liquid cola, but also with cola ice cubes. 

Place the cola ice cubes in a blender, add the Fireball, and blend until everything homogenizes. 

If you use liquid cola, pour the cola and Fireball into a shaker and shake it well until the mix gets foamy. The recommended dosage is two parts cola and one part Fireball. 

Can You Drink Fireball Neat? 

You can absolutely have Fireball neat, preferably as a shot. However, its intense cinnamon flavor and strength may not be everyone’s favorite. It is a strong beverage with a generous 33% alcohol content. 

Before you set your mind to having a Fireball shot-themed night, try a Fireball shot first to see if you can handle it. Even though it is very flavorful and delicious, Fireball has a pretty strong bite, and you would be setting yourself to disappointment if you don’t know your options. 

If the Fireball shots are too strong for you, you can always mix it to tone it down and add some extra flavor and viscosity. 


  1. https://vinepair.com/articles/9-best-fireball-whiskey-cocktails/
  2. https://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/p/11917/fireball-cinnamon-whisky-liqueur#:~:text=It’s%20certainly%20very%20cinnamony%2C%20and,the%20International%20Review%20of%20Spirits.
  3. https://www.acouplecooks.com/fireball-whiskey/#:~:text=What%20is%20Fireball%20whiskey%3F,produced%20by%20the%20Sazerac%20Company.
  4. https://tipsybartender.com/recipe/fireball-cola-slush/

Chad Smith

Meet Chad Smith, a seasoned bartender with a passion for mixology. He's the founder of Tin Roof Drink Community, a blog where he shares expert tips, creative recipes, and fosters a vibrant community of cocktail enthusiasts and aspiring bartenders. Join Chad as he takes you on a flavorful journey through the world of drinks. Cheers!

Leave a Reply